The Successful (and Deliverable!) Email Campaign
Simple Guidelines for a Successful Email Marketing Campaign
One of the many hats I wear at Thrive is the campaign fulfillment manager – every email campaign that is launched through our system is displayed on my screen, at least once. Talk about information overload!
Until recently, I also managed results. Again, every campaign that was launched appeared on my screen once more, when I reviewed and posted the open rates. Many campaigns unfortunately failed, but the successes were often statistically phenomenal! As a marketing company, we want to help every client’s campaign be an amazing success – there is nothing more rewarding than receiving the client phone call telling us to STOP his campaign, because he can’t handle the leads its generating!
How do I gauge success? In many cases, the three major statistics we provide are strong indicators: the final campaign open rate, click-thru totals and opt-out totals. A high open rate indicates that the Subject Line and From Mask were likely relevant to the list selection and contained information that the recipients were interested in finding out more about. A large number of click-thrus demonstrates that the creative gave the reader a clear reason to visit the website/landing page and learn more. A low opt-out count is also a relevancy and interest indicator. For example, our list composed of Hunters and Fishermen list may not have many individuals interested in Duck Hunting… so the Duck Call you’re selling that generated 10 click-thrus and 125 opt outs from our campaign may not be the best product for our list!
Seeing so many campaigns succeed and fail, I began noting trends of characteristics present in each category. I thought it would be appropriate to share some of these characteristics with our clients and prospective clients in order to aid in the campaign development process.
First off, characteristics of poorly performing campaigns:
- Non-descript Subject Lines and From Masks – Subject: “Check this out!” From: “Awesome”… likely not going to work.
- Deceptive Subject Lines and From Masks – touting new shoes from Tom’s in the Subject and From, but then offering Soccer balls in the creative will win you no sales and likely get your email deleted with no clickers.
- High SPAM Assassin SPAM Scores – SPAM Assassin is a widely used SPAM Filtering engine which investigates the content of a message and scores each email based on a set of carefully crafted rules. It’s best to test the score of your creative with a free score checker online.
- Poor creative design –yellow test and a pink background typically don’t go together… and your recipient knows it.
- Improper Grammar / Misspellings – You’d be surprized at the nummer of blatent mspelligns thatt sho up in e-mAilcampaignns. Proofread!
- Image-only Creatives – while using images enables you as a designer to control more of what your recipient sees, an image-only creative often results in a blank ad on his/her screen.
- Email Addresses in the Creative – email addresses included in a creative often snag a few SPAM Assassin points right away. Avoid using an email address and include a landing page (we can help with that!)
And, of course, now those of successful campaigns:
- RELEVANCE! – Relevant list pairing to your product or offering.
- Clear From Mask and Subject Lines – The FM and SL are in the “front line” when it comes to getting the recipient’s attention… they state what the email content is about and from whom it originates and often dictate whether the recipient will open or delete your email. Think about how your sort your daily snail mail…
- Clear Call-To-Action (CTA) – Blatantly provide the recipient with the next steps to take if they are interested in your offer. Simply inform them of what they should do if interested in your product.
- Design Consistency – Allow your creative design to flow from the recipient’s inbox to your website or landing page. This prevents the visitor from being concerned that he is visiting the incorrect website.
- Repetition – Multiple viewings have proven over time to increase response rates.
- Images with ALT Text – As discussed above, many email clients will hide images by default; this is detrimental to your ad, especially when the images are important to
- Colors – Extreme colors, such as fuchsia, yellow or lime-green will often trigger SPAM filters and reduce deliverability.
- Timing – Timing is critical on many fronts. If running a campaign to inform the public of a timed-event, such as a sale or webcast, send initial notification 2-weeks in advance. As the event nears, send follow-up reminders to the same recipients.
- Appropriate Text to Image ratio – Images will make an email creative “pop”, but don’t include too many images that sacrifice the deliverability of your email campaign or the appearance of the creative for those email clients that block images by default.
- Personalize, it’s free! – Where appropriate, include the recipient’s name in the email to grab their attention. Would be more likely to continue reading an email with the greeting “Dear Consumer” or “Dear [first_name]”?
As you read, many of these points may seem like common sense. Often though, it seems they are forgotten in the midst of pulling all parts of a campaign together. Prior to scheduling your campaign, review each of the above points to see if you’ve forgotten something – one minor edit may make your campaign a knock-out success!